Is the Hadith Quoted by Qurtubi regarding Four Prophetesses Authentic?
Question: What is the source and authentication of the hadith quoted by Qurtubi regarding four prophetesses?
Answer:
Wa alaykum assalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh,
Dear questioner,
Thank you for your important question.
In his tafsir, Qurtubi refutes an alleged statement of the Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace) that ‘There were indeed four prophetesses …’
The source and authenticity are unknown to me. I have tried to find it in many works but to no avail.
Dr. Abdullah Abd al Muhsin al Turki mentions in his 2006 24-volume edition of Qurtubi’s tafsir, that he and his team were also unable to find the hadith.
In light of this, the hadith is most likely weak or fabricated.
Short answer:
The majority opinion is that there were no female prophets.
Allah Most High says, ‘And We sent not before you [as messengers] except men to whom We revealed from among the people of cities.’ (Qur’an, 12: 109)
The wisdom behind this is that Allah has generally given roles of authority and leadership to men.
Fuller answer:
Equal before Allah
Both men and women are equal before Allah, in that both have an equal opportunity of drawing near to Him.
Allah Most High says, ‘Indeed, Muslim men and Muslim women, believing men and believing women, obedient men and obedient women, truthful men and truthful women, patient men and patient women, humble men and humble women, charitable men and charitable women, fasting men and fasting women, men who guard their private parts and women who do so, and men who remember Allah often and women who do so – for them Allah has prepared forgiveness and a great reward.’ (Qur’an, 33:35)
And Allah Most High says, ‘Verily the noblest of you in the sight of Allah is the most God-fearing of you.’ (Qur’an, 49: 13)
We learn from these verses that Allah looks at our hearts, and does not look to our gender.
Women in leadership
Allah has said in the Quran, ‘Men are in charge of women because We have given more to some than others.’ [4: 34]
The general trend in Allah’s religion is that men are in leadership roles, such as being the caliph, judgeship, leading the household, and leading the Eid and Friday prayers, etc..
A woman can be and do many things: they can lead other women in prayer, be politicians, muftis, CEOs, millionaires, writers, revolutionists, mothers, astronauts … But there is a general hierarchy in things that touch the structure and performance of the Muslim community.
For this reason, Allah sent men to fulfill the greatest role of leadership, that of prophethood.
Please see:
https://seekers.flywheelstaging.com/answers/shafii-fiqh/how-should-women-pray-in-congregation-in-the-shafii-school/
https://seekers.flywheelstaging.com/answers/shafii-fiqh/can-women-student-representatives/
Women in religious scholarship
Just because women have a limited role in leadership, it doesn’t mean that they cannot be scholars.
In his list of jurists of the Prophetic Companions, Ibn Hazm mentions Our Mother Aisha at the very top of the list. (Ashab al Futya min al Sahaba wa al Tabiin, Ibn Hazm). Shaykh Akram Nadwi has compiled a forty-volume book on just female hadith narrators alone. (Al-Muhaddithat Scholars, Mohammad Akram Nadwi)
Clearly, learning, and teaching both women and men is something Muslim women have done and can do.
Please see:
Female Prophets
The vast majority of scholars have held that there has never been a female prophet. (Tuhfa al Murid, Bajuri) This is because of the verse ‘And We sent not before you [as messengers] except men to whom We revealed from among the people of cities.’ (Qur’an, 12: 109)
Some scholars opined that there were indeed female prophets. Ibn Hazm held that Our Mothers Eve, Sara, the mother of Musa (upon whom be peace), Hajar, and Asiya, and Maryam (Allah be well-pleased with them all) were prophetesses; and Qurtubi held that Our Lady Maryam was a prophetess. (Al Milil wa al Nihal, Ibn Hazm; Jami Ahkam al Qur’an, Qurtubi)
Female Role Models
Perhaps the questioner asked the question in her search for individuals to act as role models in her life. After all, it is always easier to take as an example of someone who is more similar to you in gender, age, and background, etc..
There are countless biographies of outstanding women who may be emulated: Our Mothers Khadija, Aisha, Umm Salama, etc. among many, many others of Prophetic Companions, and early Muslims, all of whom can offer realistic, human, powerful, and deeply moving examples of what it means to worship Allah as a woman.
Please see: https://www.idealmuslimah.com/personalities/sahaabiyaat.html
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2o4KSz_Mt4U
Conclusion
The majority opinion is that there were no female prophets, the wisdom being that roles of authority and leadership are normally assigned to men.
There are nevertheless countless women in the history of Islam whose lives can serve as role models for Muslim women and girls.
I pray this helps.
[Ustadh] Farid
Checked and Approved by Shaykh Faraz Rabbani
Ustadh Farid Dingle has completed extensive years of study in the sciences of the Arabic language and the various Islamic Sciences. During his studies, he also earned a CIFE Certificate in Islamic Finance. Over the years he has developed a masterful ability to craft lessons that help non-Arabic speakers gain a deep understanding of the language. He currently teaches courses in the Arabic Language
